Written for the
booknook October review-a-thon.
Title: Consider the Consequences
Authors: Doris Webster & Mary Alden Hopkins
Genre: Romance
Helen Rogers has fallen for wealthy rake Jed Harringdale. Her parents would rather she married the dull but dependable Saunders Mead. Which way should she turn? It's up to the reader to decide: Jed, Saunders, or a much more exciting path that involves neither of them...
Consider the Consequences was first published in 1930 and is believed to be the first gamebook-- the form which was later popularized by the Choose Your Own Adventure series. For years there were only a few known surviving copies, locked up in academic libraries and private collections, but in 2025 Pushkin Press stepped forward to issue a reprint.
There are three sections. The first and longest is about Helen, who can choose a suitor or instead go to the big city, get a job, and possibly make a deliberate choice to live as a single mother. The second is about Jed choosing how much to grow up or not, and the third concerns Saunders, forced to take over as the head of his family after his father's untimely death and try to provide for his younger siblings.
Webster and Hopkins wrote the book to be a party game. The introduction suggests reading it aloud and allowing the audience to vote. It also anticipates that people may wish to bookmark a section and come back to it to see how the other choice would go. A full map of each section is also provided for anyone who might want to just check out all the endings.
The big contrast with most later gamebooks is that where the genre is now dominated by fantasy and science fiction adventures, Consider the Consequences is about navigating adulthood. Each story covers years of time. There are divorces, deaths, second chances at love, and sometimes opportunities to correct past mistakes.
Each ending concludes with a paragraph of the form, "The consequence of this character making this choice/being this sort of person is..." but not typically in a moralizing tone. Instead the point is usually about choosing how to live with one's fellow human beings and to take care of oneself. Almost a hundred years later, it still holds up very well.
Title: Consider the Consequences
Authors: Doris Webster & Mary Alden Hopkins
Genre: Romance
Helen Rogers has fallen for wealthy rake Jed Harringdale. Her parents would rather she married the dull but dependable Saunders Mead. Which way should she turn? It's up to the reader to decide: Jed, Saunders, or a much more exciting path that involves neither of them...
Consider the Consequences was first published in 1930 and is believed to be the first gamebook-- the form which was later popularized by the Choose Your Own Adventure series. For years there were only a few known surviving copies, locked up in academic libraries and private collections, but in 2025 Pushkin Press stepped forward to issue a reprint.
There are three sections. The first and longest is about Helen, who can choose a suitor or instead go to the big city, get a job, and possibly make a deliberate choice to live as a single mother. The second is about Jed choosing how much to grow up or not, and the third concerns Saunders, forced to take over as the head of his family after his father's untimely death and try to provide for his younger siblings.
Webster and Hopkins wrote the book to be a party game. The introduction suggests reading it aloud and allowing the audience to vote. It also anticipates that people may wish to bookmark a section and come back to it to see how the other choice would go. A full map of each section is also provided for anyone who might want to just check out all the endings.
The big contrast with most later gamebooks is that where the genre is now dominated by fantasy and science fiction adventures, Consider the Consequences is about navigating adulthood. Each story covers years of time. There are divorces, deaths, second chances at love, and sometimes opportunities to correct past mistakes.
Each ending concludes with a paragraph of the form, "The consequence of this character making this choice/being this sort of person is..." but not typically in a moralizing tone. Instead the point is usually about choosing how to live with one's fellow human beings and to take care of oneself. Almost a hundred years later, it still holds up very well.